Skip to main content

Comparison of fine-needle aspiration and fine-needle capillary sampling of thyroid nodules: a prospective study with emphasis on the influence of nodule size.

Zhou JQ, Zhang JW, Zhan WW, Zhou W, Ye TJ, Zhu Y, Yao JJ, Liu J, Hu YY, Grant EG

Publication: Cancer Cytopathol (2014) • Vol 122 • Page 266-73PMID: 24302655View on PubMed

Purpose

The purpose of this paper was to compare diagnosis and specimen quality scores among case-matched fine-needle aspiration (FNA) and fine-needle capillary (FNC) specimens from thyroid nodules. The effect of nodule size on sampling efficiency was also investigated.

Conclusion

On average, FNA specimens were of higher quality (i.e. lower blood contamination, adequate cellularity and tissue preservation, and less cellular degeneration) and were more likely to result in a diagnosis than FNC specimens. Nodule size significantly affected scores for cellularity, tissue preservation, cellular degeneration, and the cumulative score in FNC specimens but not FNA specimens. Diagnostic agreement between FNA and FNC specimens was highest when nodules were between 10.1 and 20.00 mm in diameter, as these specimens did not differ among procurement methods in blood contamination, cellularity, tissue preservation, cellular degeneration, and cumulative scores. Finally, FNA specimens that were collected from nodules that were between 10.1 and 20.0 mm in diameter had higher scores for cellularity, tissue preservation, and cellular degeneration than nodules that were between 5.1 and 10.00 mm in diameter.

Studies (1)

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to compare diagnosis and specimen quality scores among case-matched FNA and FNC specimens from thyroid nodules, and to investigate an effect of nodule size. FNA and FNC specimens were obtained with a 22-gauge needle using ultrasound guidance from 280 thyroid nodules from 275 patients. The order of collection was FNA then FNC from 140 nodules, and FNC then FNA from the remaining 140 nodules. Both FNA and FNC sampling involved inserting the needle into the nodule and moving it back and forth within the nodule until the specimen appeared in the needle hub; however, a 10-mL syringe was attached to the needle and suction was applied for FNA specimens while the needle was not attached to a syringe for FNC specimens. FNA and FNC specimens were placed on glass slides, ethanol-fixed, and H&E stained. Specimens were scored based on blood contamination, cellularity, and cellular degeneration. A score of 0 was assigned when diagnosis was not possible, a score of 1 if diagnosis was possible, and a score of 2 when diagnosis was easy. Tissue architecture was graded as 0 if minimally preserved thus preventing diagnosis, 1 if there was some preservation (visible follicles or papillae), or 2 if well-preserved permitting easy diagnosis. A cumulative score of 0-2 was considered inadequate for diagnosis, 3-5 was adequate for diagnosis and 6-8 was superior for diagnosis. In addition, the final cytopathologic finding was adequate if the specimen contained at least 6 groups that contained10 or more follicular cells.

Summary of Findings

Overall, diagnosis was not possible in 15% of FNA specimens and 20.7% of FNC specimens, but the difference in the percentage of non-diagnostic specimens was only significant for nodules >20.00 mm (10.0% for FNA versus 26% for FNC, P=0.037). The cytopathologic diagnostic agreement between FNA and FNC specimens increased with increasing follicle size up to 10.1-20.0 mm (κ=0.377 for nodules of ≤5.0 mm, κ=0.455 for nodules of 5.1 - 10.0 mm, and κ=0.751 for nodules of 10.1 - 20.0 mm), but then decreased to κ=0.352 for nodules >20.00 mm. Scores for blood contamination, cellularity, tissue preservation, and cellular degeneration were higher for FNA than FNC specimens (p<0.001, all); but when broken down by nodule size, the differences were only significant for nodules measuring 5.1 - 10.00 mm (P=0.003, P=0.001, P<0.001 and P<0.001, respectively) or >20.0 mm (P=0.013, P=0.007, P=0.005 and P=0.004). Further, the mean cumulative quality score was higher for FNA than FNC specimens (5.66 versus 5.08, P<0.001), but the difference was only significant for nodules measuring 5.1 - 10.00 mm (5.75 versus 4.82, P<0.001) and nodules >20.0 mm (5.82 versus 4.70, P=0.003). While scores for specimen quality were not affected by nodule size for FNA specimens scores for cellularity, tissue preservation, cellular degeneration, and the cumulative score differed among nodules of different sizes for FNC specimens (P=0.010, P=0.010, P=0.030, and P=0.022, respectively). Importantly, for FNC specimens significantly higher scores for cellularity, tissue preservation, and cellular degeneration were obtained in nodules that were 10.1 - 20.0 mm than those that were 5.1 - 10.00 mm (P=0.024, P=0.041 and P=0.043, respectively). Tissue preservation and cumulative scores were higher in FNC specimens from nodules that were 10.1 - 20.0 mm than those that were <5.0 mm (P=0.042 and P=0.048, respectively). Finally, FNA specimens were more likely to result in a cumulative score of 6 - 8 (superior) than FNC specimens (P=0.011); however, when the specimen set was broken down by nodule size the difference was only significant in nodules that were 5.1 - 10.0 mm (P=0.013) or >20.00 mm (P=0.045), and there were no differences in the percentage of specimens that were diagnostically adequate (cumulative score of 3 - 5).

  • Biospecimens

    CellThyroid Gland
  • Preservation Types

    Ethanol
  • Diagnoses

    NeoplasticCarcinoma
    NeoplasticBenign
    Not specified
  • Platforms

    MorphologyH-and-E microscopy
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    PreaquisitionPrognostic factor
    10.1-20.0 mm nodule
    5.1-10.0 mm nodule
    <5.0 mm nodule
    >20 mm nodule
    Biospecimen AcquisitionMethod of cell acquisition
    FNA
    FNC