This paper compared the morphology of specimens differentially preserved by formalin-fixation and paraffin embedding; snap-freezing and OCT embedding; or RNAlater (4°C or -150°C) followed by OCT-embedding. DNA and RNA purity and integrity of snap frozen and RNAlater-preserved, OCT-embedded specimens were also compared. The analytical suitability of DNA and RNA extracted from specimens that were RNAlater-preserved, OCT-embedded was also discussed.
Next-generation biobanking of metastases to enable multidimensional molecular profiling in personalized medicine.
Diaz Z, Aguilar-Mahecha A, Paquet ER, Basik M, Orain M, Camlioglu E, Constantin A, Benlimame N, Bachvarov D, Jannot G, Simard MJ, Chabot B, Gologan A, Klinck R, Gagnon-Kugler T, Lespérance B, Samson B, Kavan P, Alcindor T, Dalfen R, Lan C, Chabot C, Buchanan M, Przybytkowski E, Qureshi S, Rousseau C, Spatz A, Têtu B, Batist G
Purpose
Conclusion
Optimal morphological preservation was observed with the FFPE specimen but suitable preservation was observed among OCT-embedded, snap-frozen specimens, and specimens preserved in RNAlater (at 4˚C) and washed in PBS prior to OCT-embedding. Specimens preserved in RNAlater but not washed prior to OCT-embedding did not stain consistently and when frozen, did not adhere to slides. DNA and RNA yield and purity as determined by spectrophotometer and RNA integrity numbers (RIN) were comparable between OCT-embedded snap-frozen specimens and those preserved in RNAlater (at 4˚C) and washed prior to OCT-embedding, but DNA yield was more variable among RNAlater-preserved, OCT-embedded specimens. Importantly, specimens preserved in RNAlater (at 4˚C) and washed prior to OCT-embedding were found to be suitable for comparative genomic hybridization (CGH), methylation, splicing, and transcriptome analysis.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This study compared the morphology of formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded (FFPE) specimens; OCT-embedded, snap-frozen specimens; and OCT-embedded, RNAlater-preserved specimens stored at 4˚C or -150˚C with or without washing in PBS. DNA and RNA purity and integrity of OCT-embedded snap-frozen and RNAlater-preserved specimens was also compared. The analytical suitability of DNA and RNA extracted from specimens that were RNAlater-preserved, OCT-embedded was also discussed. Multiple biopsies were obtained using a 16-gauge BioPince full-core, end-cutting, tri-axial automated biopsy device from hepatectomy specimens of patients diagnosed with colorectal cancer. Specimens were: (A) fixed in formalin for 48 h at room temperature and embedded in paraffin, (B) snap frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at -150˚C for 72 h and embedded in OCT, (C) stored in RNA later at 4˚C for 72 h and OCT-embedded, (D) stored in RNA later at -150˚C for 72 h, washed in PBS on dry ice, and OCT-embedded, or (E) stored in RNAlater at 4˚C for 72 h, washed in PBS on dry ice, and OCT embedded. All OCT-embedded specimens were stored at -80˚C until sectioning at -20˚C. All specimens were sectioned at 5 µM. DNA and RNA were isolated from snap-frozen specimens and specimens stored in RNAlater at 4˚C for 72 h and washed in PBS on dry ice using the Qiagen AllPrep DNA/RNA Mini Kit. To investigate the suitability of protocol E for molecular analysis, biopsies containing >60% tumor and <20% necrotic cells were obtained from each of 3 patients and neoplastic cells were removed by macrodissection using an H&E stained reference slide.
Summary of Findings
Optimal morphological preservation was observed with the FFPE specimen, but suitable preservation was observed among OCT-embedded, snap-frozen specimens and specimens preserved in RNAlater at 4˚C, washed in PBS, then OCT-embedded (protocol E). RNAlater-preserved specimens that were OCT-embedded but not washed (protocols C and D) did not stain consistently and when frozen, did not adhere to slides. Despite containing 100% tumor, the authors contend some specimens contained so many necrotic and stromal cells that there were not enough neoplastic cells for molecular analysis. DNA and RNA yield and purity as determined by spectrophotometer and RNA integrity numbers (RIN) were comparable between the OCT-embedded, snap-frozen specimens and RNAlater-preserved specimens (4˚C) that were washed prior to OCT-embedding, but DNA yield was more variable among RNAlater specimens, which the authors attribute to increased difficulty in homogenization. High molecular weight DNA was obtained from the OCT-embedded, snap-frozen specimens and RNAlater-preserved (4˚C) specimens that were washed prior to OCT-embedding. DNA from RNAlater-preserved (4˚C) specimens that were washed prior to OCT-embedding was sufficient to detect the expected chromosomal gains (20q, 13 and 8q) and losses (18, 20 and 8p) by array cGH, as well as to detect global hypomethylation and hypomethylation of the CpG islands in Jun proto-oncogene (JUN), FBJ murine osteosarcoma viral oncogene homolog (FOS), and avian myelocytomatosis viral oncogene homolog (MYC). Using RNA isolated from the three RNAlater-preserved, OCT-embedded specimens it was possible to detect all 138 microRNAs (miRNA) on the low density array, 79 of 96 alternative splice events analyzed using a high-throughput RT-PCR method, and 12,999 expressed genes on the microarray. Importantly, 12 of 25 miRNA previously implicated in colorectal cancer were upregulated in all three specimens and mRNA levels were strongly correlated among the specimens (r=0.88-0.91). Finally, when the data was combined, RNA levels, methylation status, and copy number results all agreed with one another.
Biospecimens
TissueLiverPreservation Types
FormalinRNAlaterOCTDiagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaPlatforms
DNASpectrophotometryMorphologyH-and-E microscopyRNALow density arrayRNAAutomated electrophoresis/BioanalyzerRNASpectrophotometryRNADNA microarrayRNART-PCRDNAArray CGHDNABisulfite conversion assayDNAElectrophoresisPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Temperature of fixation/preservation -150˚C4˚CBiospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation Formalin (buffered)RNAlaterSnap frozenAnalyte Extraction and Purification Washing Not washedWashed in PBSBisulfite conversion assay Specific Targeted nucleic acid FOSJUNMYCDNA microarray Specific Technology platform Methylation arrayaCGH