The purpose of this paper was to compare tyrosine phosphatase and phosphatase and tensin homolog (PTEN) activities in lysates obtained from normal, diseased, malignant and benign thyroid tissue specimens that were thawed at different temperatures prior to lysate preparation.
Effect of Thaw Temperatures in Reducing Enzyme Activity in Human Thyroid Tissues
Kokkat T, McGarvey D, Lovecchio L, LiVolsi V
Purpose
Conclusion
Thawing snap-frozen thyroid tissue specimens at 95°C resulted in significant reductions in tyrosine phosphatase activity in diseased, malignant and benign thyroid tissue lysates, in comparison to tissue specimens that were not thawed, or thawed at traditional thaw temperatures (4°C and 37°C) prior to lysate preparation; however, the magnitude and statistical significance of the differences were dependent on the protein concentration used in the assay. Thaw temperature did not affect tyrosine phosphatase activity in lysates from normal thyroid tissues. Thawing tissues at a high temperature led to lower PTEN activity compared to unthawed specimens or those thawed at 4 or 37°C, but statistically significant differences were only observed for normal and diseased thyroid specimens.
Studies (1)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to compare tyrosine phosphatase and PTEN activities in lysates obtained from normal, diseased, malignant and benign thyroid tissue specimens that were thawed at different temperatures prior to lysate preparation. Thyroid samples of comparable weights and sizes were snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at -80°C prior to thawing. Specimens were processed without thawing or thawed on ice for 4-6 min (4°C), in an oven for 10 min (37°C), or using a Stabilizor T1 system, which uses a combination of vacuum and laser to achieve 95°C. Lysates were calorimetrically measured for tyrosine phosphatase at various protein concentrations (1, 0.5 and 0.1 µg/µL) and PTEN activity at 1 µg/µL protein.
Summary of Findings
Frozen thyroid tissue thawed using a novel temperature (95°C) in the absence of enzymatic inhibitors showed a reduction in tyrosine phosphatase activity in tissue lysates when compared to traditional thaw temperatures (4°C and 37°C) in diseased, malignant and benign tissues; however, the magnitude and statistical significance of differences were dependent on thaw temperature, protein concentration, and diagnosis. There was no effect of thaw temperature on tyrosine phosphatase activity in normal tissues. PTEN activity was lower when thyroid tissue was thawed at 95°C compared to unthawed specimens or those thawed at 4 or 37°C, but statistically significant differences were only observed in normal or diseased specimens (not malignant or benign specimens).
Biospecimens
TissueThyroid GlandPreservation Types
FrozenDiagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaNormalNeoplasticBenignGraves DiseaseHashimoto's ThyroiditisPlatforms
ProteinEnzyme assayProteinSpectrophotometryPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Preaquisition Diagnosis/ patient condition Benign (Goiter, Adenoma or Fibrosing thyroiditis)Diseased (Grave’s disease or Hashimoto’s thyroiditis)Malignant (Papillary carcinoma)NormalStorage Thaw temperature/condition 37°C ovenIce (4°C)Not thawedStabilizor T1 (95°C)Enzyme assay Specific Reaction volume 0.1 ug/ul substrate0.5 ug/ul substrate1 ug/ul substrate