Will PAXgene substitute formalin? A morphological and molecular comparative study using a new fixative system.
Belloni B, Lambertini C, Nuciforo P, Phillips J, Bruening E, Wong S, Dummer R
Purpose
Conclusion
Studies (2)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of method of fixation on morphological preservation and IHC staining using 12 melanoma biopsy specimens from skin and lymph node metastases. A portion of each specimen was either embedded in optimal cutting temperature compound (OCT) and snap frozen in liquid nitrogen, fixed in formalin for 24 h at room temperature and embedded in normal paraffin, or fixed for 2-4 h at 4 degrees C in PAXgene fixative, transferred to PAXgene Tissue Stabilization Reagent for at least 24 h, and embedded in low melting paraffin. PAXgene paraffin blocks were stored at 4 degrees C in the dark while formalin blocks were stored at room temperature in the dark.
Summary of Findings
There were no significant differences in morphological preservation between FFPE specimens and PAXPE specimens. Significantly weaker IHC staining was observed in PAXPE tissue than FFPE tissue for b-Raf, microphthalmia-associated transcription factor (MITF), cyclinD1 (CCND1), melanoma-associate antigen 4 (MAGEA4), and Tyrosinase, but protocols employed were specifically developed for FFPE tissue. No statistically significant differences in immunostaining intensity were seen for 6 other antigens. The authors report that a higher concentration of antibody improved Ki67 immunostaining in PAXPE which was initially insignificantly lower than that seen in FFPE tissue, but altering antibody concentration did not improve p53 immunostaining intensity in PAXPE (also insignificantly lower than FFPE), and altering antigen retrieval pH did not improve CCND1 or p53 immunostaining in PAXPE tissue. The addition of NP-40 to staining reactions was able to increase MITF, p53, and CCND1 immunostaining in PAXPE tissue.
Biospecimens
TissueLymph NodeTissueSkinPreservation Types
PAXgeneFormalinFrozenDiagnoses
NeoplasticMelanomaPlatforms
ProteinImmunohistochemistryMorphologyH-and-E microscopyPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation Formalin (buffered)PAXgeneSnap frozenAnalyte Extraction and Purification Antigen retrieval No antigen retrievalpH 6pH 9Analyte Extraction and Purification Cell/tissue permeabilization NP-40No NP-40Immunohistochemistry Specific Antibody dilution/concentration 1:1001:10001:2001:500Immunohistochemistry Specific Targeted peptide/protein CCND1Ki67MAGEA4MITFMelanAS100Tyrosinaseb-Rafc-Kitp16p53
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of method of fixation on DNA and RNA analysis using 12 melanoma biopsy specimens from skin and lymph node metastases. A portion of each specimen was either embedded in OCT and snap frozen in liquid nitrogen, fixed in formalin for 24 h at room temperature and embedded in normal paraffin, or fixed for 2-4 h at 4 degrees C in PAXgene fixative, transferred to PAXgene Tissue Stabilization Reagent for at least 24 h, and embedded in low melting paraffin. PAXgene paraffin blocks were stored at 4 degrees C in the dark while formalin blocks were stored at room temperature in the dark. DNA was extracted from PAXgene and formalin-fixed tissue using the BiOstic Tissue DNA Isolation kit. RNA was extracted from PAXgene-fixed specimens using the PAXgene Tissue RNA kit, from formalin-fixed specimens using the BiOstic FFPE Tissue RNA Isolation Kit, and from snap frozen specimens using Trizol.
Summary of Findings
There were no significant differences in DNA or RNA purity, as measured by spectrophotometry, between preservation method-specific extraction methods. Increasing fragment length decreased amplification success for both PAXPE and FFPE tissue in real time qRT-PCR and qPCR assays while the same was not true of frozen specimens (only tested in real time qPCR assays). This effect was more pronounced for DNA and RNA extracted from FFPE tissue than for that extracted from PAXPE tissue. While the largest Abelson murine leukemia viral oncogene homolog 1 (ABL1) mRNA fragment (806 bp) failed to amplify for either PAXPE or FFPE specimens, amplificability of the shorter two ABL1 fragments (114 bp and 398 bp) as well as Tyrosinase mRNA was generally better in PAXPE specimens than FFPE specimens. Real time qPCR amplification of BCL6 corepressor (BCOR) and calcium channel, voltage-dependent, gamma subunit 4 (CACNG4) was also generally more successful using DNA from PAXPE specimens than FFPE specimens. For about half of the specimens, the real time qPCR amplification quality of BCOR or CACNG4 was similar to or better for the PAXPE specimens than the frozen specimens.
Biospecimens
TissueLymph NodeTissueSkinPreservation Types
PAXgeneFormalinFrozenDiagnoses
NeoplasticMelanomaPlatforms
DNAReal-time qPCRDNAPCRDNASpectrophotometryRNAReal-time qRT-PCRRNASpectrophotometryPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation Formalin (buffered)PAXgeneSnap frozenAnalyte Extraction and Purification Analyte isolation method BiOstic FFPE Tissue RNA Isolation KitBiOstic Tissue DNA Isolation kitPAXgene Tissue RNA kitTrizolReal-time qRT-PCR Specific Length of gene fragment 108 bp114 bp338 bp398 bp589 bp712 bp806 bpReal-time qRT-PCR Specific Targeted nucleic acid ABL1 kinaseTyrosinaseReal-time qPCR Specific Length of gene fragment 117 bp145 bp275 bp277 bp553 bp571 bpReal-time qPCR Specific Targeted nucleic acid BCL6CACNG4