Skip to main content

RNA quality in frozen breast cancer samples and the influence on gene expression analysis--a comparison of three evaluation methods using microcapillary electrophoresis traces.

Strand C, Enell J, Hedenfalk I, Fernö M

Publication: BMC Mol Biol (2007) • Vol 8 • Page 38PMID: 17519006View on PubMed

Purpose

The purpose of this paper was to compare different RNA quality assessment methods (and their respective thresholds), and to determine if RNA degradation alters relative levels of specific transcripts. Results of a timecourse study that was aimed to introduce RNA degradation by thawing specimens at room temperature was also discussed.

Conclusion

For the majority of specimens, RNA degradation was apparent after a thaw duration of 10 min at room temperature. When evaluation methods were compared using case-matched specimens exposed to different cold ischemia times, 83% of specimens produced RNA quality results that were concordant for all three methods; however, concordance was highest (96%) between visual inspection and RIN methods. Unsupervised hierarchical clustering analysis of microarray data of specimens from the same tumor that were subjected to different cold ischemia times produced two main groups: specimens with good or partly degraded RNA, and those with degraded RNA. This pattern of clustering was observed for each evaluation method and the respective quality thresholds imparted. However, the number of samples that did not cluster based upon the RNA quality pattern described above did differ among assessment methods, as visual inspection of bioanalyzer data yielded the fewest number of samples that clustered outside of the RNA quality pattern while the ratio method yielded the most. The authors conclude that determination of RNA quality using the visual inspection method or by RIN is preferable to the ratio method.

Studies (1)

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to compare different RNA quality assessment methods and to determine if RNA degradation affects relative levels of specific transcripts. Three different methods of RNA quality assessment using bioanalyzer data was examined: visual inspection, which was based upon the presence of two distinct ribosomal RNA peaks and a flat baseline; the ratio method, which was based on a threshold of 0.65; and RNA integrity number (RIN), which was based on a threshold of 6. Breast tumors collected from six patients were frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at -80 degrees C before analysis. Frozen specimens were divided and case-matched aliquots were thawed at room temperature in a timecourse study to introduce RNA degradation.

Summary of Findings

For the majority of specimens, RNA degradation was apparent after a thaw duration of 10 min, although 2 of the 6 specimens were affected after 2-3 min at room temperature, and 1 remained unaffected after 30 min. When evaluation methods and respective quality thresholds were compared by pair-wise comparisons, 83% (20/24) of specimens displayed concordant results for all three methods. Concordance for RNA quality determination was highest (96%; 23/34) between visual inspection and RIN methods. Unsupervised hierarchical clustering analysis of gene expression profiles determined by microarray from samples collected from the same tumor but subjected to different cold ischemia times produced two main groups: specimens with good or partly degraded RNA, and those with degraded RNA. This pattern of clustering was observed for each evaluation method and the respective quality thresholds imparted. However, the number of samples that did not cluster based upon the RNA quality pattern described above did differ among assessment methods, as visual inspection of bioanalyzer data yielded 1 sample that clustered outside of the RNA quality pattern while the ratio method yielded 5 samples. When microarray data was assigned into two groups based upon RIN threshold (RIN <6, RIN ≥6), 9 of the 10 genes that were differentially expressed between the two groups were present at lower levels in samples with a RIN <6.

  • Biospecimens

    TissueBreast
  • Preservation Types

    Frozen
  • Diagnoses

    NeoplasticCarcinoma
  • Platforms

    RNAAutomated electrophoresis/Bioanalyzer
    RNADNA microarray
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    StorageThaw duration
    10 min
    2-3 min
    30 min
    50 s
    Automated electrophoresis/Bioanalyzer SpecificQuality metrics
    RIN
    Ratio method
    Visual inspection