This paper investigated the effect of using formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) rather than fresh tissue specimens on the MammaPrint profile. The authors also investigate the effect of tumor sample size on RNA yield.
MammaPrint molecular diagnostics on formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue.
Sapino A, Roepman P, Linn SC, Snel MH, Delahaye LJ, van den Akker J, Glas AM, Simon IM, Barth N, de Snoo FA, van 't Veer LJ, Molinaro L, Berns EM, Wesseling J, Riley LB, Anderson D, Nguyen B, Cox CE
Purpose
Conclusion
RNA yield was modestly associated with tumor sample size (r=0.45). All four G6PD amplicons were amplifiable from the FFPE RNA, and there was a 97% success rate for amplification, labeling and microarray analysis of FFPE RNA. The expression levels of the 70 genes making up the MammaPrint profile were highly reproducible, with 96% concordance between specimens of the same tumor sectioned on different days. Further, the MammaPrint profile was highly concordant (96%) between laboratories. The MammaPrint profile in matched FFPE and fresh specimens was strongly correlated for both the low-risk (r=0.881) and high risk (r=0.832) classifications. When validated using 211 specimens, the correlation between MammaPrint indices for FFPE and fresh specimens was very strong (r=0.917), and the risk categorization matched for 91.5% of specimens. Importantly, expression levels of the normalization genes were very strongly correlated between different FFPE specimens (r=0.9955-0.9967).
Studies (1)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of using FFPE rather than fresh specimens on the MammaPrint profile and the effect of tumor sample size on RNA yield. 157 FFPE specimens were used to optimize the assay, and cohorts of 125 and 211 matched FFPE and fresh specimens were used for comparisons. RNA was extracted from 2 10 µm sections or 4 5µm sections using the RNeasy FFPE kit and underwent whole transcriptome amplification.
Summary of Findings
RNA yield was modestly associated with tumor sample size (r=0.45). All four G6PD amplicons were amplifiable from the FFPE RNA, and there was a 97% success rate for amplification, labeling and microarray analysis of FFPE RNA. The expression levels of the 70 genes making up the MammaPrint profile were highly reproducible, with 96% concordance between specimens of the same tumor sectioned on different days. Further, the MammaPrint profile was highly concordant (96%) between laboratories. The MammaPrint profile was strongly correlated between matched FFPE and fresh specimens for both the low-risk (r=0.881) and high risk (r=0.832) classifications. When validated using 211 specimens, the correlation between MammaPrint indices of FFPEand fresh specimens was very strong (r=0.917) and the risk categorization matched for 91.5% of specimens. Importantly, expression levels of the normalization genes were very strongly correlated between different FFPE specimens (r=0.9955-0.9967).
Biospecimens
TissueBreastPreservation Types
FormalinNone (Fresh)Diagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaPlatforms
RNART-PCRRNADNA microarrayRNASpectrophotometryPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Preaquisition Prognostic factor High-riskLow-riskBiospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation Formalin (buffered)None (fresh)Storage Storage duration Sectioned at different timesRT-PCR Specific Length of gene fragment 123 bp145 bp177 bp91 bp