STRs, mini STRs and SNPs--a comparative study for typing degraded DNA.
Senge T, Madea B, Junge A, Rothschild MA, Schneider PM
Purpose
The purpose of this paper was to determine the effects of environmental exposure, DNase I- induced degradation of DNA, and kit/assay type on the results of single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) and short tandem repeat (STR) analysis using blood and saliva specimens.
Conclusion
The Mentype Nonaplex QS assay yielded the lowest success rates (successfully typed markers/total number of markers for that particular kit or assay) when blood or saliva soaked cotton was exposed to the environment, compared to the other SNP and STR kits/assays. On the other hand, the minisequencing SNaPshot assay gave the highest success rates when typing the DNA samples from blood soaked cotton that had been exposed to the environment for up to 22 weeks or saliva soaked cotton that had been exposed to the environment for up to 12 weeks. DNA yields from blood generally decreased after 10 weeks of environmental exposure and continuously from the start of environmental exposure for saliva specimens. When DNA was artificially degraded by DNase I treatment, the 5' nuclease assays and the Nonaplex QS kit yielded the lowest success rate, while the minisequencing SNaPshot assay and the MPX-SP1/2 kits were the most compatible with DNase I treated DNA samples.
Studies (2)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of environmental exposure, DNase I- induced degradation of DNA, and kit/assay type on the results of SNP and STR analysis using blood specimens. Environmental exposure consisted of leaving blood soaked cotton outside in sunlight, rain, and various ambient temperatures for a given period of time. The authors do not report whether DNase I treated DNA was extracted from blood or saliva.
Summary of Findings
The Mentype Nonaplex QS assay yielded the worst results when blood soaked cotton was exposed to the environment with an over 20% decline in success rate after just 2 weeks of exposure. The minisequencing SNaPshot assay showed the highest success rates when typing the DNA samples from blood soaked cotton that had been exposed to the environment for up to 22 weeks, followed by the MPX-SP1/2 kits, and next, the 5' nuclease assays which failed to yield results after 18 weeks of specimen exposure. DNA yields from blood decreased after 10 weeks of environmental exposure, but were back on par with yields obtained with no environmental exposure after 12 weeks. However, after that point, DNA yields generally showed a decreasing trend until no DNA was recovered after 24 weeks of environmental exposure. When DNA was artificially degraded by DNase I treatment, the 5' nuclease assays and the Nonaplex QS kit yielded the worst success rates, while the minisequencing SNaPshot assay and the MPX-SP1/2 kits were the most compatible with DNase I treated DNA samples and had 100% success rates even when samples were treated with up to 1/40 units (U) DNase I.
Biospecimens
FluidBloodPreservation Types
None (Fresh)Diagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
DNASNP assayDNAMicrosatellite analysisDNAReal-time qPCRPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Storage Storage duration 0 weeks10 weeks12 weeks14 weeks16 weeks18 weeks2 weeks20 weeks22 weeks24 weeks4 weeks6 weeks8 weeksAnalyte Extraction and Purification Nucleic acid digestion 1 U DNase I1/10 U DNase I1/100 U DNase I1/1000 U DNase I1/2 U DNase I1/20 U DNase I1/200 U DNase I1/4 U DNase I1/40 U DNase I1/400 U DNase I1/6 U DNase I1/60 U DNase I1/600 U DNase I1/8 U DNase I1/80 U DNase I1/800 U DNase I15 U DNase I3 U DNase I30 U DNase I7 U DNase ISNP assay Specific Technology platform 5' nuclease assayMinisequencing SNaPshot assayMicrosatellite analysis Specific Technology platform MPX-SP1MPX-SP2Mentype Nonaplex QS
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of environmental exposure, DNase I- induced degradation of DNA, and kit/assay type on the results of SNP and STR analysis using saliva specimens. Environmental exposure consisted of leaving saliva soaked cotton outside in sunlight, rain, and various ambient temperatures for a given period of time. The authors do not report whether DNase I treated DNA was extracted from saliva or blood.
Summary of Findings
The Mentype Nonaplex QS assay yielded the worst success rates when saliva soaked cotton was exposed to the environment with almost a 40% decline in success rate after just 2 weeks of exposure. The minisequencing SNaPshot assay showed the highest success rates when typing the DNA samples from saliva soaked cotton that had been exposed to the environment for up to 12 weeks, followed by the MPX-SP1/2 kits, and next, the 5' nuclease assays which failed to yield results after 6 weeks of specimen exposure. Throughout environmental exposure, DNA yields decreased. No DNA was recovered from any specimens at the 6 week time point or the 14 week time point. When DNA was artificially degraded by DNase I treatment, the 5' nuclease assays and the Nonaplex QS kit yielded the lowest success rates, while the minisequencing SNaPshot assay and the MPX-SP1/2 kits were the most compatible with DNase I treated DNA samples and had 100% success rates even when samples were treated with up to 1/40 U DNase I.
Biospecimens
FluidSalivaPreservation Types
None (Fresh)Diagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
DNASNP assayDNAMicrosatellite analysisDNAReal-time qPCRPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Storage Storage duration 0 weeks10 weeks12 weeks14 weeks2 weeks4 weeks6 weeks8 weeksAnalyte Extraction and Purification Nucleic acid digestion 1 U DNase I1/10 U DNase I1/100 U DNase I1/1000 U DNase I1/2 U DNase I1/20 U DNase I1/200 U DNase I1/4 U DNase I1/40 U DNase I1/400 U DNase I1/6 U DNase I1/60 U DNase I1/600 U DNase I1/8 U DNase I1/80 U DNase I1/800 U DNase I15 U DNase I3 U DNase I30 U DNase I7 U DNase ISNP assay Specific Technology platform 5' nuclease assayMinisequencing SNaPshot assayMicrosatellite analysis Specific Technology platform MPX-SP1MPX-SP2Mentype Nonaplex QS