Risk of Alzheimer's disease biological misdiagnosis linked to cerebrospinal collection tubes.
Perret-Liaudet A, Pelpel M, Tholance Y, Dumont B, Vanderstichele H, Zorzi W, Elmoualij B, Schraen S, Moreaud O, Gabelle A, Thouvenot E, Thomas-Anterion C, Touchon J, Krolak-Salmon P, Kovacs GG, Coudreuse A, Quadrio I, Lehmann S
Purpose
This paper investigated collection tube choice as a source of pre-analytical variability in the quantification of several biomarkers of Alzheimer's Disease (AD) in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF).
Conclusion
Sampling tubes made of polypropylene (PP), polystyrene (PS), or a polypropylene and polyethylene (PP-PE) copolymer yielded significant differences in the concentrations of each of the three AD biomarkers investigated in CSF. Effects were dependent on the biomarker quantified; for example, the concentration of amyloid-beta peptides (AB) displayed the greatest variation between tube types (-48%/+31%) while phosphorylated Tau (p-Tau181P) displayed the lowest variation. Accordingly, the authors postulate that quantification of AB peptides in CSF, but not other markers, carries a risk of misdiagnosis for AD. An analysis of tube composition determined that effects could not be linked to composite material. Post-collection storage of CSF specimens in new tubes for up to 24 hours at 2-8 degrees C prior to freezing did not alter effects compared to specimens stored at room temperature for 15 min. An artificial increase in protein content abolished tube-dependent effects, leading the authors to postulate that CSF specimens with low protein content are particularly susceptible to potential biomarker adsorption to the surface of the tube.
Studies (2)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to investigate the chemical composition of collection tubes as a source of pre-analytical variability of three biomarkers of AD in CSF (AB; total tau protein, hTau; p-Tau181P). CSF specimens (2 ml) were collected from 12 patients by lumbar puncture directly into 4 different commercial tubes made of either polypropylene (PP) (Sarstedt 10 ml, Becton Dickinson 15 ml) or polystyrene (PS) (Fisher Scientific hemolysis tube 5 ml, Becton Dickinson 14 ml). CSF specimens were then stored on ice, centrifuged, aliquoted, and stored at -80 degrees C for less than 6 months before analysis.
Summary of Findings
AB40 and AB42 concentrations differed significantly among all four types of collection tubes examined (p<0.05), with the highest concentrations observed in CSF specimens collected into polypropylene tubes from Sarstedt followed by Fisher Scientific's hemolysis polystyrene were also present, with significantly lower concentrations among CSF specimens collected in polystyrene tubes from Becton Dickinson compared to either brand of polypropylene tubes. For p-Tau181P, significant differences in concentration was limited to CSF specimens collected into Fisher Scientific's hemolysis polystyrene tubes compared to other tube types (p<0.05). The authors note that the magnitude of variation attributable to tube type carries a potential risk for AD misdiagnosis for AB40 and AB42, but not other markers.
Biospecimens
FluidCerebrospinal FluidPreservation Types
FrozenDiagnoses
Alzheimer's DiseasePlatforms
PeptideELISAProteinELISAPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Type of collection container/solution Becton Dickinson 14 ml tube (PS)Becton Dickinson 15 ml tube (PP)Fisher Scientific hemolysis tube 5 ml (PS)Sarstedt 10 ml tube (PP)ELISA Specific Targeted peptide/protein AB40AB42hTaup-Tau181P
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to assess potential differences in AD biomarkers levels in CSF stored in polypropylene collection tubes from different manufacturers for different lengths of time prior to analysis. CSF specimens from 6 patients were collected directly into Falcon 15 ml polypropylene tubes before centrifugation, aliquoting and storage in one of 11 commercial collection tubes for 15 min at room temperature or 24 hours at 2-8 degrees C prior to frozen storage at -80 degrees C. The chemical composition of each tube was verified by differential scanning calorimetry and Fourier Transformed Infrared spectroscopy. Tube composition consisted of polypropylene (PP), a polypropylene and polyethylene copolymer (PP-PE), or polypropylene, polyethylene and an unknown copolymer (PP-PE+Unknown).
Summary of Findings
Significant differences in AB1-42, hTau, and pTau (p<0.05) levels were present between specimens stored in the different polypropylene-containing tubes Maximum median variations were highest for AB 1-42 (-48%/+31%), but within a range deemed acceptable by the authors for hTau (-8%/+8%) and p-Tau181P (-4%/+6%). Effects of storage tube type were present in specimens stored for 15 min or 24 h and significant differences were not present between the two timepoints. Artificially increasing protein content abolished tube-type effects over time, supporting the author's hypothesis of AD biomarker adsorption to the tube surface. The authors suggest that AD biomarker thresholds should be specific to collection tube type and handling protocols.
Biospecimens
FluidCerebrospinal FluidPreservation Types
FrozenDiagnoses
Alzheimer's DiseasePlatforms
PeptideELISAProteinELISAPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Type of collection container/solution CML 15 ml tube (PP-PE)Deltalab 12 ml tube (PP-PE)Evergreen 30 ml tube(PP-PE)Falcon 14 ml tube (PP-PE)Falcon 15 ml tube (PP-PE)Gosselin 5 ml tube (PP)Greiner 15 ml tube (PP-PE)Nalgene 2 ml tube (PP-PE, unknown copolymer)Sarstedt 10 ml tube (PP-PE, unknown copolymer)Storage Storage duration 15 min24 hELISA Specific Targeted peptide/protein AB1-42hTaup-Tau181P