Skip to main content

Effectiveness of practices to reduce blood sample hemolysis in EDs: a laboratory medicine best practices systematic review and meta-analysis.

Heyer NJ, Derzon JH, Winges L, Shaw C, Mass D, Snyder SR, Epner P, Nichols JH, Gayken JA, Ernst D, Liebow EB

Publication: Clin Biochem (2012) • Vol 45 • Page 1012-32PMID: 22968086View on PubMed

Purpose

The purpose of this review paper was to perform meta-analysis to determine if straight needle venipuncture versus IV catheter collection, location of IV catheter, collection into a syringe versus vacuum tubes, and needle gauge affect the rates of hemolysis among blood specimens from previously published and unpublished studies.

Conclusion

Meta-analysis found that using a straight needle rather than an IV catheter and placing an IV catheter in an antecubital site rather than a distal site significantly reduced the risk ratio (RR) and would thereby lead to a reduction in hemolysis rates among specimens collected using those methods. Using an IV start, syringe draws rather than vacuum tube draws did not significantly reduce the RR for hemolysis. Evidence that larger needles (21 gauge or lower) can reduce hemolysis rates was of "insufficient" strength, and evidence that blood collection into a partial/low vacuum tube versus a full vacuum tube can reduce hemolysis rates was deemed "suggestive" rather than "high".

Studies (1)

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of straight needle venipuncture versus IV catheter collection, location of IV catheter, use of a syringe draw versus vacuum tubes, and needle gauge on the rates of hemolysis among blood specimens from previously published and unpublished studies. Studies included were given a study quality rating based on the CDC-sponsored Laboratory Medicine Best Practices Initiative's "A-6 Cycle" systematic review methods.

Summary of Findings

Meta-analysis found the reduction in hemolysis rates among straight needle draws to be approximately 84% (RR=0.16) with a strength rating of "high", when compared to IV catheter blood collection (11 studies). Meta-analysis determined the reduction in hemolysis rates among antecubital IV catheters to be approximately 55% (RR=0.45), also with a strength rating of "high" compared to IV catheters in distal sites (4 studies). Meta-analysis determined the reduction in hemolysis rates among syringe draws versus vacuum tube draws to be 3% (RR=0.97) and not significant (3 conflicting studies). While 2 "fair" studies reported there were substantial reductions in hemolysis rates when needle gauges of 21 or less (larger) were used, the single study rated "good" found the effect to be minimal or absent. Meta-analysis determined the reduction in hemolysis rates when needle gauges of 21 or less (larger) were used, as opposed to smaller needles, to be 63% (RR=0.37), although the strength of the evidence was deemed "insufficient" due to heterogeneous results. Meta-analysis of the effects of collecting blood in a partial vacuum tube versus a full vacuum tube on hemolysis rates revealed an 89% reduction in hemolysis rates when a low vacuum tube was used (RR=0.11) based on 1 published and 1 unpublished study. However, the strength of the evidence in this case was rated as "suggestive" rather than "high".

  • Biospecimens

    FluidBlood
  • Preservation Types

    None (Fresh)
  • Diagnoses

    Not specified
  • Platforms

    Cell count/volumeSpectrophotometry
    Cell count/volumeMacroscopic observation
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionAnatomical location of blood draw
    Anticubital vein
    Distal vein
    Biospecimen AcquisitionMethod of fluid acquisition
    IV catheter
    Needle
    Syringe draw
    Vacuum tube
    Biospecimen AcquisitionNeedle gauge
    21 gauge or less (larger)
    >21 gauge (smaller)
    Biospecimen AcquisitionType of collection container/solution
    Full vacuum tube
    Partial/low vacuum tube