Sources of Variability Between Biobanks in the Estimation of DNA Concentration
Jury F, Morris J, Davis E, Ollier W E, Yuille M
Publication: Biopreservation and Biobanking (2012) • Vol 10 • Page 55-61
Purpose
The purpose of this paper was to determine the effects of several analytical variables on the accuracy of DNA concentration measurement in samples extracted from pooled blood.
Conclusion
With qPCR results taken as the standard, absorption spectroscopy was more accurate than fluorescence spectroscopy for the measurement of DNA concentration, the latter giving lower measurements. In particular, use of a Nanodrop for absorption spectroscopy, as opposed to other instruments, led to increased accuracy in DNA concentration measurement. Importantly, the authors state that centers using the Nanodrop for absorption spectroscopy were less likely to dilute their samples, and sample dilution was associated with decreased accuracy for absorption spectroscopy. The authors state that sample dilution did not significantly affect the accuracy of fluorescence spectroscopy. Averaging two or more measurements was associated with increased accuracy for fluorescence spectroscopy, and this variable was not addressed for absorption spectroscopy. Mixing time of the DNA sample and the time the liquid handling device was last serviced did not affect the accuracy of DNA concentration measurement overall, but the authors state that these variables may possibly influence the two technologies differently.
Studies (1)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of several analytical variables on the accuracy of DNA concentration measurement in samples extracted by phenol/chloroform from pooled blood. 72 centers participated in measuring DNA concentrations of 8 stock solutions (prepared from the same 45-specimen pool) by their usual methods. The stock solutions consisted of 8, 31, 77, 137, 178, 222, 236, and 335 ng DNA/uL as measured by real time qPCR.
Summary of Findings
With qPCR results taken as the standard, absorption spectroscopy was more accurate than fluorescence spectroscopy for the measurement of DNA concentration, the latter giving lower measurements. In particular, use of a Nanodrop for absorption spectroscopy, as opposed to other instruments, led to increased accuracy in DNA concentration measurement. Importantly, the authors state that centers using the Nanodrop for absorption spectroscopy were less likely to dilute their samples, and sample dilution was associated with decreased accuracy for absorption spectroscopy. The authors state that sample dilution did not significantly affect the accuracy of fluorescence spectroscopy. Averaging two or more measurements was associated with increased accuracy for fluorescence spectroscopy, and this variable was not addressed for absorption spectroscopy. The authors state that mixing time of the DNA sample and the time the liquid handling device was last serviced did not affect the accuracy of DNA concentration measurement overall, but the authors suggest that these variables may possibly influence the two technologies differently. Interestingly, the authors state that all data sets from centers performing fluorescence microscopy indicated that samples were mixed, while 16% of absorption spectroscopy data sets were from unmixed samples. The authors state that there were no significant differences between the use of the Picogreen broad range kit and the Picogreen narrow range kit or between different excitation frequencies, but measurements taken at lower emission frequencies were associated with increased accuracy.
Biospecimens
FluidBloodPreservation Types
None (Fresh)Diagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
DNAReal-time qPCRDNASpectrophotometryDNAFluorometryPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Analyte Extraction and Purification Sample mixing 1-5 min16-30 min31-60 min6-15 min<1 minNo mixingOvernightVariable durationsFluorometry Specific Data handling One measurementTwo or more measurements averagedFluorometry Specific Detection method Picogreen broad range kitPicogreen narrow range kitUnspecified range of emission frequenciesUnspecified range of excitation frequenciesFluorometry Specific Frequency of servicing More than 18 months agoNeverNot applicableUnknownWithin 13-18 monthsWithin 6 monthsWithin 7-12 monthsFluorometry Specific Template/input amount Diluted sampleUndiluted sampleSpectrophotometry Specific Data handling One measurementTwo or more measurements averagedSpectrophotometry Specific Frequency of servicing More than 18 months agoNeverNot applicableUnknownWithin 13-18 monthsWithin 6 monthsWithin 7-12 monthsSpectrophotometry Specific Technology platform 17 instruments comparedSpectrophotometry Specific Template/input amount Diluted sampleUndiluted sampleReal-time qPCR Specific Technology platform FluoremetrySpectrophotometry