Tissue microarrays compared with whole sections and biochemical analyses. A subgroup analysis of DBCG 82 b&c.
Kyndi M, Sørensen FB, Knudsen H, Overgaard M, Nielsen HM, Andersen J, Overgaard J
Purpose
The purpose of this paper was to determine if the use of tissue microarray cores, at different locations both within and between different paraffin blocks affects the reproducibility of estrogen receptor (ER), progesterone receptor (PR) and human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER-2) case status determined by immunohistochemistry. Comparisons were also drawn between immunohistochemical analysis of whole sections and biochemical analysis of tumor homogenates.
Conclusion
Proportional agreements in receptor case status among TMA cores and corresponding whole sections were antigen-dependent although trends common to all three antigens were observed. Proportional agreement in cases status was greater when two TMA cores from the center of the tumor were compared as opposed to the periphery, and relatively unaffected by the addition of up to four TMA cores. Although proportional agreements for case status ranged from almost perfect to substantial for all three antigens when the number and location of TMA cores were compared to one another or to a whole section, Kappa values (k) were still lower than those observed when two whole sections were compared. The percent agreement for case status between a TMA core and a corresponding whole section was reported as 62% and 67% for ER and PR, respectively. Use of TMA cores for immunohistochemistry was further validated by comparing resultant ER and PR case status with biochemical determinations of free cytolosolic ER and PR in tumor homogenates, revealing an 85% agreement for ER status (k=0.64) and a 82% agreement for PR (k=0.62).
Studies (2)
Purpose
Proportional agreement (represented by the Kappa value, k) between receptor case status was determined by immunohistochemical analysis of (1) a 1.0 mm TMA core and a corresponding whole section, (2) 1.0 mm TMA cores taken from the center or periphery of the same paraffin block, (3) 1.0 mm cores taken from the same location of two different paraffin blocks, and (4) whole sections from two different paraffin blocks. A total of 108 paraffin blocks from 27 patients were examined.
Summary of Findings
Proportional agreements in receptor case status among TMA cores and corresponding whole sections were antigen-dependent. When a corresponding TMA core and whole section were compared almost perfect agreements were reported for ER (k=0.81), and substantial agreements for PR (k=0.70) and HER-2 (k=0.67). Similarly, comparisons between TMA cores punched at the core or periphery of a paraffin block revealed almost perfect agreement for ER (k=0.83) and PR (k=0.80) case status, and substantial agreement for HER-2 (k=0.73). When TMA cores taken from two different paraffin blocks were compared, the proportional agreement was higher among cores taken from the center as opposed to the periphery for all three antigens, ER (k=0.89 versus 0.77), PR (k=0.65 versus 0.54), and HER-2 (k=0.78 versus 0.69). Agreements among TMA cores did not increase when all four TMA cores were compared for ER (k=0.83), PR (k=0.67), or HER-2 (k=0.73). Importantly, agreements among TMA cores were lower than agreements between whole sections from two different paraffin blocks, which approached perfect for all three antigens investigated (ER, k=0.92; PR, k=1.00; HER-2, k=0.95). An additional source of variability included discrepancies among observers. Although the Kappa values reported above represent an average, observer values were reported separately in the manuscript and interobserver agreement was determined to be substantial for both TMA cores (k=0.75) and whole sections (k=0.65). The percent agreement between a TMA core and a corresponding whole section was reported as 62% and 67% for ER and PR respectively, although the case status criteria differed between proportional agreement analysis (for which a positive case was defined as nuclear staining in greater than 10% of invasive tumor cells) and percent agreement (for which a positive case was defined as nuclear staining in more than 10 or 50 invasive tumor cells in a TMA core or whole section, respectively).
Biospecimens
TissueBreastPreservation Types
FormalinDiagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaPlatforms
ProteinImmunohistochemistryProteinTissue microarrayPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Aliquots and Components Aliquot size/volume Single paraffin blockTwo paraffin blocksBiospecimen Aliquots and Components Biospecimen heterogeneity Biospecimen coreBiospecimen peripheryBiospecimen Aliquots and Components Type of slide Tissue microarray coreWhole tissue sectionImmunohistochemistry Specific Targeted peptide/protein ERHER-2PR
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine if ER and PR case status can accurately be determined by immunohistochemistry of a single 1.0 mm TMA core. The percentage of ER and PR positive and negative cases determined by immunohistochemistry and the Dextran Coated Charchoal (DCC) assay were compared in 580 and 534 patients, respectively. Criteria for positive receptor status by immunohistochemistry and the DCC assay was set at nuclear staining in greater than 10% of invasive tumor cells or 10 fmol/mg cytosol protein, respectively.
Summary of Findings
Comparison of ER and PR status by immunohistochemical analysis of a single TMA core and biochemical quantification of free cytolosolic ER and PR in tumor homogenates reveals a 85% agreement for ER status (k=0.64) and a 82% agreement for PR (k=0.62). The majority of discrepant cases were characterized by low DCC values and a negative immunohistochemistry status.
Biospecimens
TissueBreastPreservation Types
FormalinDiagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaPlatforms
ProteinImmunohistochemistryProteinTissue microarrayProteinReceptor bindingPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Immunohistochemistry Specific Technology platform Dextran Coated Charcoal AssayImmunohistochemistry