Formaldehyde substitute fixatives: analysis of macroscopy, morphologic analysis, and immunohistochemical analysis.
Moelans CB, Ter Hoeve N, van Ginkel JW, Ten Kate FJ, van Diest PJ
Purpose
Conclusion
Studies (2)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of fixative type and time in fixative on morphological preservation of 17 different tissue types.
Summary of Findings
Histological staining was more intense in tissues fixed with F-Solv and less intense in tissues fixed with RCL-2 or FineFIX compared to formalin-fixed specimens. Formalin was best for specimen integrity and tissue preservation followed by F-Solv and RCL-2 fixation. Fixation with RCL-2 or FineFIX resulted in red blood cell lysis, loss of eosinophilic cytoplasmic granules, and tissue shrinkage, but nuclear details were best preserved in RCL-2 fixed specimens. Only formalin fixation allowed for structure recognition in lymph nodes. Fixation duration had a limited effect on staining, but in specimens fixed for 2 months, structures were difficult to recognize, especially in specimens fixed with F-Solv. The authors report the penetration speed for FineFIX and RCL-2 was similar to that of formalin, but that F-Solv did not adequately penetrate large specimens, even after fixation for 2 months. While formalin-, FineFIX- and RCL-2-fixed specimens yielded good results with most histological stains tested, F-Solv-fixed specimens were given insufficient or intermediate scores in most cases.
Biospecimens
TissuePlacentaTissueLiverTissueBrainTissueEsophagusTissueStomachTissueSmall BowelTissueColorectalTissueLungTissueBreastTissueAdrenal GlandTissueKidneyTissueLymph NodeTissueThyroid GlandTissueTonsilTissueSpleenTissueGall BladderPreservation Types
FormalinOther PreservativeDiagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
MorphologyLight microscopyMorphologyH-and-E microscopyPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Time in fixative 1-2 months1-2 weeks2-4 days24 h4 hBiospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation F-SolvFineFIXFormalin (buffered)RCL2Light microscopy Specific Type of tissue stain Alcian blueAzanElastic van-GiesonGordon-SweetJones silver stainPeriodic acid-SchiffPeriodic acid-Schiff diastase
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of fixative type, time in fixative and antigen retrieval method on IHC staining of 17 different tissue types.
Summary of Findings
IHC staining was best in formalin-fixed specimens followed by RCL-2-, FineFIX- and F-Solv-fixed specimens. IHC staining of chromogranin A was good, regardless of fixative. IHC staining for estrogen receptor (ER) was inadequate in specimens fixed with the formalin alternatives. Staining for progesterone receptor (PR) and p63 was intermediate or lower in specimens fixed with the formalin alternatives. S-100 staining was suboptimal in the colonic nerve plexi fixed with the formalin alternatives, but optimal staining was achieved in F-Solv-fixed neurilemmoma. CD45, creatinine kinase, and cytokeratin AE1/3 staining were inadequate in F-Solv-fixed specimens, regardless of pretreatment. The authors report that pretreatment steps recommended for formalin-fixed specimens often did not improve staining of specimens fixed with the alternative fixatives, but alternate treatments such as pepsin digestion improved staining in some cases.
Biospecimens
TissuePlacentaTissueLiverTissueBrainTissueEsophagusTissueStomachTissueSmall BowelTissueColorectalTissueLungTissueBreastTissueAdrenal GlandTissueKidneyTissueLymph NodeTissueThyroid GlandTissueTonsilTissueSpleenTissueGall BladderPreservation Types
FormalinOther PreservativeDiagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
ProteinImmunohistochemistryPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Time in fixative 1-2 months1-2 weeks2-4 days24 h4 hBiospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation F-SolvFineFIXFormalin (buffered)RCL2Analyte Extraction and Purification Antigen retrieval CitrateEDTAPepsinImmunohistochemistry Specific Targeted peptide/protein AE1/3CAM5.2CD45Chromogranin AERPRS-100Vimentinp63