Formaldehyde substitute fixatives: effects on nucleic acid preservation.
Moelans CB, Oostenrijk D, Moons MJ, van Diest PJ
Purpose
Conclusion
Studies (2)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of type and duration of fixation on DNA yield, maximum amplicon size, sequencing and microsatellite analysis using 17 tissue types including omentum. DNA was extracted using DNeasy from 3 sections of each paraffin-embedded specimen.
Summary of Findings
The highest DNA yields were obtained from tissues fixed in RCL-2 (2.2 x formalin yield). Similar DNA yields were obtained from specimens fixed with FineFIX or formalin, but less and lower purity DNA was obtained from specimens fixed with F-Solv. While 300 bp was the maximum amplicon size obtained from specimens fixed with formalin, 400 bp fragments were amplified from specimens fixed with RCL-2, F-Solv, or FineFIX. Fixation for 4 h, rather than 24 h, did not increase maximum amplicon length, but led to increased DNA yield. EGFR sequence was not affected by fixative type, but bands from F-Solv-fixed tissues were less pronounced, and bands from RCL-2-and FineFIX-fixed specimens were more pronounced than those from specimens fixed in formalin. Microsatellite instability analysis had higher signals when the specimens were fixed in FineFIX or RCL-2, but extra, non-interfering, small peaks were also identified in these specimens. F-Solv-fixed specimens often had low signal and high background when analyzed by fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) or chromogenic in situ hybridization (CISH), while FineFIX-fixed specimens had the highest signal for these analyses.
Biospecimens
TissuePlacentaTissueLiverTissueBrainTissueEsophagusTissueStomachTissueSmall BowelTissueColorectalTissueLungTissueBreastTissueAdrenal GlandTissueKidneyTissueLymph NodeTissueThyroid GlandTissueTonsilTissueSpleenTissueGall BladderTissueOtherPreservation Types
FormalinOther PreservativeDiagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
DNADNA sequencingDNASpectrophotometryDNAPCRDNAFISHPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Time in fixative 24 h4 hBiospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation F-SolvFineFIXFormalin (buffered)RCL2PCR Specific Length of gene fragment 100 bp200 bp300 bp400 bpPCR Specific Targeted nucleic acid EGFRSpecimen control size ladderFISH Specific Targeted nucleic acid Alpha centromereCEP15 chromogenic
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of fixative type and time in fixative on RNA yield and maximum amplicon size using 17 tissue types including omentum. RNA was extracted using RNeasy from 2-12 sections of each paraffin-embedded specimen.
Summary of Findings
Less RNA was extracted from specimens fixed with F-Solv (0.7 fold) than formalin, and more RNA was extracted from specimens fixed with FineFIX (2.0 fold) or RCL-2 (5.3 fold) than from formalin-fixed specimens. The A260/280 ratio was highest from RCL-2-fixed specimens (2.07) followed by those fixed with FineFIX (1.96), F-Solv (1.80) and formalin (1.63), but RIN numbers were not affected by fixative type. RNA yield and quality were not affected by time in fixative. Real-time PCR cycle threshold values were lowest for RCL-2- and FineFIX-fixed specimens and similar for formalin- and F-Solv-fixed specimens.
Biospecimens
TissuePlacentaTissueLiverTissueBrainTissueEsophagusTissueStomachTissueSmall BowelTissueColorectalTissueLungTissueBreastTissueAdrenal GlandTissueKidneyTissueLymph NodeTissueThyroid GlandTissueTonsilTissueSpleenTissueGall BladderTissueOtherPreservation Types
FormalinOther PreservativeDiagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
RNAFluorometryRNAReal-time qRT-PCRRNAAutomated electrophoresis/BioanalyzerPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Preservation Time in fixative 24 h4 hBiospecimen Preservation Type of fixation/preservation F-SolvFineFIXFormalin (buffered)RCL2Real-time qRT-PCR Specific Targeted nucleic acid GAPDH