Skip to main content

Buccal swabs and treated cards: methodological considerations for molecular epidemiologic studies examining pediatric populations.

Beckett SM, Laughton SJ, Pozza LD, McCowage GB, Marshall G, Cohn RJ, Milne E, Ashton LJ

Publication: Am J Epidemiol (2008) • Vol 167 • Page 1260-7PMID: 18326872View on PubMed

Purpose

The purpose of this paper was to compare buccal cell collection methods and to determine whether whole genome amplification (WGA) is suitable for single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) analysis.

Conclusion

DNA from BuccalAmp swabs was more fragmented than that from FTA cards. SNP analysis failed in 1.3% of samples from BuccalAmp swabs prior to WGA and in 6.3% of samples after WGA. Importantly, real time PCR analysis of beta-actin was inhibited by the use of BuccalAmp DNA extraction kits. SNP analysis was successful for all samples from FTA cards both before and after WGA. Further, 100% concordance of genotype calls was observed in specimens regardless of collection method prior to and after WGA. In conclusion, the quality of buccal cell DNA obtained from FTA cards was superior to that from BuccalAmp swabs, and WGA successfully improved the DNA yield without causing genotype errors.

Studies (1)

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to compare buccal cell collection by BuccalAmp swabs and FTA cards with respect to DNA yield and quality and to determine whether WGA is suitable for SNP analysis. Specimens taken from leukemia patients were either processed immediately when collected during a clinic visit or within 24 hours if mailed to the clinic. All specimens from control subjects were mailed to the clinic and processed within 24 hours.

Summary of Findings

Average buccal cell DNA yields from BuccalAmp swabs were significantly higher from leukemia patients than from control subjects, both before (79.1 ng vs. 26.3 ng) and after (350.0 ng vs. 78.8 ng) WGA. The authors postulate that this may be due to DNA degradation from delayed transportation as all control specimens were mailed while some patient specimens were collected in house. DNA obtained from BuccalAmp swabs ranged in quantity from undetectable (<0.01 ng/ul) to 2.6 ug. Buccal cell collection using FTA cards showed no significant differences in average DNA yield measured after WGA between patients and control subjects (240.0 ng vs. 257.0 ng). Patient age had no significant influence on DNA yield. Multiplex PCR revealed that DNA from BuccalAmp swabs was more fragmented than that from FTA cards. SNP analysis failed in 1.3% of samples from BuccalAmp swabs prior to WGA and in 6.3% of samples after WGA, but in none of the FTA specimens before or after WGA. Importantly, a 100% concordance of genotype calls was observed in specimens regardless of collection method prior to and after WGA. Real-time PCR amplification of beta-actin was inhibited by the use of BuccalAmp DNA extraction kits. In conclusion, the quality of buccal cell DNA obtained from FTA cards was superior to that from BuccalAmp swabs, and WGA successfully improved the DNA yield without impacting genotype results.

  • Biospecimens

    CellBuccal
  • Preservation Types

    None (Fresh)
  • Diagnoses

    Not specified
    NeoplasticLeukemia
  • Platforms

    DNAPCR
    DNAReal-time qPCR
    DNASNP assay
    DNAWhole genome amplification
  • Pre-analytical Factors

    ClassificationPre-Analytical FactorValue(s)
    PreaquisitionDiagnosis/ patient condition
    Acute lymphoblastic leukemia
    No acute lymphoblastic leukemia
    PreaquisitionPatient age
    Less than 16 years
    Biospecimen AcquisitionMethod of cell acquisition
    BuccalAmp swab
    FTA card
    StorageBetween site transportation method
    Mailed
    Not transported
    StorageStorage temperature
    -20 degrees C
    Room temperature
    SNP assay SpecificNucleic acid amplification
    CYP3A4 A392G
    SXR C25385T
    Real-time qPCR SpecificTargeted nucleic acid
    Beta-actin