Analysis of five sampling methods for the preparation of cervical smears.
Boon ME, de Graaff Guilloud JC, Rietveld WJ
Purpose
Conclusion
Studies (1)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to compare 5 cervical smear sampling methods. Specimens were collected by method A, method B, rotating the tip of cytopick in endocervical canal then rotating the spatula end in the ectocervix (method C), rotating a moistened cotton swab in endocervical canal and then rotating a spatula in the ectocervix (method D), or rotating a cervex brush 5 times in contact with ectocervix/endcervix (E).
Summary of Findings
The performance of the sampling methods was dependant on the sample taker (p<0.01). On average, only 0.78% of specimens collected by method B lacked EC, but 2.06% collected by method C, 4.38% collected by method E, 7.34% collected by method D and 9.29% collected by method A lacked EC. Although no differences in the detection of infectious changes or agents were found, the methods did differ significantly as to the diagnosis of CIN. Method B was the best for detection of CIN I-II (4.38%) and CIN III (2.17%), but overall differences between methods for detection of CIN were slight. The authors conclude that method B is the optimal method of cervical smear collection and methods A and D are not suitable.
Biospecimens
CellCervixPreservation Types
Other PreservativeDiagnoses
Not specifiedOther diagnosesPlatforms
MorphologyLight microscopyPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Preaquisition Diagnosis/ patient condition Cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN)Biospecimen Acquisition Method of cell acquisition Cervex brushCotton swab plus spatulaCytobrush plus spatulaCytopickSpatula