Influence of Blood Specimen Collection Method on Various Preanalytical Sample Quality Indicators
Ashavaid TF, Dandekar S, Keny B, Bhambhwani VR
Purpose
Conclusion
Studies (1)
Purpose
The purpose of this study was to compare various preanalytical specimen quality indicators using blood specimens collected either through open collection using a needle and syringe with either disposable tubes or re-useable glass vials, or through closed collection using the BD Vacutainer blood collection system including vacuum tubes. Evaluated specimen quality indicators included loss of specimen, loss of order form, specimen ID/order form mismatch, missing specimen ID, insufficient specimen volume, collection container over- or under-filled, specimen contaminated, fibrin clot after centrifugation, and hemolysis. In addition, the use of a laboratory/hospital information system to keep track of reports and requisition forms was compared to manual data management.
Summary of Findings
For every specimen quality variable that was evaluated, the use of BD Vacutainer closed collections, compared with open syringe/needle collection into either a BD Vacutainer disposable tube or a glass vial, resulted in significantly less incidences per 10,000 specimens (extrapolated numbers) with two exceptions. For 3 specimens out of 10,000 using the closed collection method, the tubes were overfilled, and this never occurred after open collection. Also, while 0 specimens collected via the closed method leaked, only 1 in 10,000 leaked after open collection which is not as significant an improvement as seen for the other variables. Importantly only 6 in 10,000 closed collected specimens showed any degree of hemolysis (visually identified through serum color), and only 3 in 10,000 were contaminated. For specimens collected via open collection, 563 in 10,000 displayed some degree of hemolysis and 137 in 10,000 were contaminated. Closed collection was performed at a facility that used a laboratory/hospital information system to keep track of reports and requisition forms, as opposed to manual data management at the facility where open collections were performed. As a result, sample ID/tracking related errors occurred significantly fewer times for specimens obtained via closed collection than for open collection methods. When comparing the use of BD Vacutainer disposable tubes with washable glass vials in the open collection procedure, the disposable tubes fared better for all preanalytical quality variables except under-filling of the collection container. Glass vials were under-filled 203 times in 10,000 while the disposable tubes were under-filled 296 times in 10,000. Nevertheless, these same disposable tubes were only under-filled 18 times in 10,000 when closed collection methods were used.
Biospecimens
FluidSerumFluidBloodPreservation Types
None (Fresh)Diagnoses
Not specifiedPlatforms
Cell count/volumeMacroscopic observationMorphologyMacroscopic observationPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Biospecimen Acquisition Data management Hospital/laboratory information systemManual data managementBiospecimen Acquisition Method of fluid acquisition Syringe drawVacuum tubeBiospecimen Acquisition Type of collection container/solution BD Vacutainer tubeGlass vial