Impact of RNA degradation on gene expression profiles: assessment of different methods to reliably determine RNA quality.
Copois V, Bibeau F, Bascoul-Mollevi C, Salvetat N, Chalbos P, Bareil C, Candeil L, Fraslon C, Conseiller E, Granci V, Mazière P, Kramar A, Ychou M, Pau B, Martineau P, Molina F, Del Rio M
Purpose
This paper performed a comparative assessment of four different techniques for determining RNA quality from surgically excised, snap frozen specimens, as well as assess microarray performance. Reliable RNA thresholds for each technique were also identified.
Conclusion
The authors report that evaluation of RNA quality using the 28S/18S ratio may lead to exclusion of RNA samples that would have performed reliably on microarray chips. RNA integrity number and degradometer values were better predictors of RNA quality for reliable microarray performance, as was the authors' own RNA-electropherogram-profile evaluation method. These evaluation methods, combined with a post-hybridization clustering analysis of full chip expression, provide stringent criteria upon which to identify samples that would give reliable or unreliable microarray results.
Studies (1)
Purpose
This paper performed a comparative assessment of four different techniques for determining RNA quality from surgically excised, snap frozen specimens, as well as assess cDNA microarray performance. The tissues employed originated in patients with liver-metastatic colorectal cancer and included normal colon, tumorous colon, and tumourous liver.
Summary of Findings
The authors developed a novel method of RNA quality assessment (the RNA Quality Scale, RQS) based upon the presence and height of the several peaks identified by electropherogram analysis: (1) low molecular weight RNA; (2) 18S and 28S ribosomal RNA; (3) the area in between ribosomal peaks; (4) nuclear RNA. A comparison among RNA quality determination techniques revealed that the means associated with sample classification differed significantly among all methods examined. Further, specificity (the probability of detecting reliable RNA samples) was highest for the RQS, RNA integrity number (RIN), and degradometer (95-86%); while sensitivity (the probability of detecting unreliable RNA samples) was highest for the 28S/18S ratio and RQS (90-82%). Reliable RNA thresholds were also identified for each technique: 28S/18S ratio >1.63; Degradometer <8.7; RQS >3; RIN >7.8. The authors concluded that RIN, degradometer DegFact, and RQS values were the best predictors of RNA quality for reliable microarray performance. These evaluation methods, combined with a post-hybridization clustering analysis of full chip expression ("dispersion tree"), provide stringent criteria upon which to identify samples that would give reliable or unreliable microarray results.
Biospecimens
TissueColorectalPreservation Types
FrozenDiagnoses
NeoplasticCarcinomaNeoplasticNormal AdjacentPlatforms
RNAAutomated electrophoresis/BioanalyzerRNADNA microarrayPre-analytical Factors
Classification Pre-Analytical Factor Value(s) Automated electrophoresis/Bioanalyzer Specific Quality metrics 28S/18S RNA ratioDegradometer DegFactRNA Integrity Number (RIN)RNA Quality Scale (RQS)